Bright open kitchen with white cabinets, a marble island and white bar stools
On this page
  1. Cash out refinance vs HELOC: the quick answer
  2. How a cash-out refinance changes your first mortgage
  3. How a HELOC works beside your first mortgage
  4. The deciding factor: your current first-mortgage rate
  5. Cash out refinance vs HELOC: when each tends to win
  6. Costs and risks that apply to both
  7. Cash out refinance vs HELOC FAQ

Cash out refinance vs HELOC: the quick answer

In the cash out refinance vs HELOC decision, a cash-out refinance replaces your first mortgage with a bigger one, so you keep one monthly payment. A home equity line of credit (HELOC) is usually a second loan beside your first mortgage, and it leaves that loan’s rate and payment alone. A key question is how your current first-mortgage rate compares with what a new first mortgage costs today.

The reason is arithmetic: a cash-out refinance sets one new rate on the whole balance, while a HELOC prices only the new money. So the further your current rate sits below today’s rates, the more a cash-out refinance gives up. The rest of this page decides it with numbers.

Side-by-side comparison

This table draws on the comparison in the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s (CFPB) HELOC booklet, which also lists home equity loans.

Cash-out refinanceHELOCHome equity loan
What you getA lump sum at closingA credit line you draw on as neededA lump sum at closing
Your first mortgagePaid off and replacedStays as it isStays as it is
Monthly paymentsOneTwoTwo
Rate typeFixed or variableTypically variableFixed
Closing costs and feesGenerally higher, according to the CFPBVary by planVary by lender
How much you can borrowUp to a share of the home’s value, covering your balance plus the cashA share of the home’s value, minus your mortgage balanceSame as a HELOC
Main riskA new rate on your whole balance and a longer payoffA rising payment, and a line the lender can freezeNeeding a new loan if you want more cash later

How a cash-out refinance changes your first mortgage

A cash-out refinance pays off your current mortgage with a new, larger one, and you receive the difference in cash at closing. Because it is a new loan, it brings a new rate on the whole balance, a new term and new closing costs. The CFPB notes the “interest rate may be higher than your current mortgage.” For the full process, see how a cash-out refinance works, step by step.

Cash-out limits by loan type

As of November 2026, the conventional, FHA and VA programs cap the new loan as a share of your home’s value, USDA allows no cash out, and a lender may set a lower limit.

  • Conventional: Fannie Mae’s Eligibility Matrix allows a loan-to-value ratio (LTV) of 80% on a one-unit primary home and 75% on two to four units. Conventional loans need mortgage insurance only above 80% LTV (Fannie Mae Selling Guide B7-1-01), so a cash-out refinance normally has none.
  • FHA: HUD Handbook 4000.1 (II.A.8.d.v(B)(1)) caps the LTV at 80% of the Adjusted Value. In 2026, an FHA cash-out refinance also carries a 1.75% upfront mortgage insurance premium (MIP) and an annual MIP that lasts 11 years when the LTV is 90% or less. The FHA cash-out refinance guidelines give the annual rates.
  • VA: The VA Lender’s Handbook (Pamphlet 26-7, chapter 3, Table 2, and chapter 6, Topic 3) and 38 CFR 36.4306(a) cap a cash-out refinance at 100% of the home’s reasonable value. You can finance the funding fee only up to that cap; any part that would push the loan past 100% is paid at closing. In 2026, that funding fee is 2.15% for first use and 3.3% after, as the VA cash-out refinance guide explains.
  • USDA: The rule for refinancing a USDA guaranteed loan (7 CFR 3555.101(d)(3)(i)) says that, apart from exceptions in that paragraph, “no cash out is permitted for any refinance.”

How a HELOC works beside your first mortgage

A HELOC is usually a second lien: a line of credit, backed by your home, that sits behind your first mortgage. During the draw period, which “could last 10 years, for example,” according to the CFPB, you borrow as you need the money. Then comes the repayment period, often over 10 or 20 years, when payments are “often significantly higher.” For details, see how a HELOC works.

The rate moves with an index

Most HELOCs carry a variable rate made of an index plus the lender’s margin, and the CFPB names the U.S. prime rate as a common index. The Federal Reserve’s H.15 release listed the bank prime rate at 7.00% on November 10, 2026. Federal rules (12 CFR 1026.30) also require the contract to state a maximum rate if the rate can rise, so ask what it is.

Fees and the freeze rule

HELOC closing costs vary by plan, so ask for the full fee list. Under some plans, the CFPB says, lenders may charge application, appraisal, title, annual, inactivity and conversion fees, plus a cancellation fee usually within the first two or three years.

If you plan to draw later, note that a lender can freeze or reduce your line under 12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi). Grounds include a significant drop in your home’s value, a material change in your finances that leaves the lender believing you cannot repay, and default. By contrast, cash from a cash-out refinance is yours at closing.

A HELOC carries no FHA MIP and no private mortgage insurance. Even so, lenders limit your combined loan-to-value (CLTV): all loans on the home divided by its value.

The deciding factor: your current first-mortgage rate

Freddie Mac’s weekly survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% on November 12, 2026, up from 6.24% a year earlier. That survey covers conventional home-purchase loans, not cash-out refinances, so treat it only as a rough guide to what a new first mortgage costs. A cash-out refinance can price differently. HELOC rates, on the other hand, follow their own index and margin.

A worked example

Say a home is worth $500,000, and the owner owes $250,000 at 3.5% with 25 years left. That loan’s principal and interest payment is $1,251.56, and the owner wants $50,000. Every number here is hypothetical, and the rates are examples. Both options end at a CLTV of 60% ($300,000 ÷ $500,000).

  • Option A, cash-out refinance: a new $300,000 loan (the $250,000 balance plus $50,000) at a fixed 7.00% for 30 years.
  • Option B, HELOC: keep the first mortgage and open a $50,000 HELOC at 8.00%, which is the 7.00% prime rate on November 10, 2026, plus a made-up 1.00-point margin. Payments are interest-only during the draw period.
Option A: cash-out refinanceOption B: first mortgage plus HELOC
Monthly payment$1,995.91$1,584.89 ($1,251.56 plus $333.33)
Monthly payment if the HELOC is repaid over 20 yearsNot applicable$1,669.78 ($1,251.56 plus $418.22)
Interest in the first yearAbout $20,900About $12,650 ($8,650 plus $4,000)
The 3.5% first mortgageReplacedKept
TermRestarts at 30 yearsFirst mortgage still ends in 25 years

Payments are principal and interest only, without property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance or closing costs.

In this cash out refinance vs HELOC example, Option B costs about $8,250 less interest in the first year and has the lower monthly total. That is because the 3.5% rate on $250,000 stays in place. Option A also stretches the whole balance over a new 30 years.

How much the variable rate can add

Each 1 percentage point on a $50,000 interest-only balance adds $41.67 a month ($50,000 × 1% ÷ 12). At 10%, the HELOC payment would be $416.67, for a total of $1,668.23. At 11%, it would be $458.33, for a total of $1,709.89. Even that stays below Option A here. Still, a larger HELOC balance or a smaller gap between your rate and today’s rates would narrow the difference.

When the math favors the cash-out refinance

The result reverses when your current first-mortgage rate is at or above what a new first mortgage would cost. A cash-out refinance may then cost no more than a second lien, and it gives you one payment with a fixed-rate option.

These figures are examples, not quotes. A lender’s Loan Estimate for a refinance, or its HELOC disclosures, controls your real numbers. To test your own case, put your balance, rate and remaining term into the same arithmetic.

Cash out refinance vs HELOC: when each tends to win

No option fits every borrower, but some patterns hold.

A cash-out refinance tends to fit when

  • Your current first-mortgage rate is at or above today’s rates.
  • The cash goes to one large project or bill, needed all at once.
  • A single fixed payment matters more to you than keeping a low rate.
  • Staying put for years gives you time to absorb the higher closing costs.

A HELOC tends to fit when

  • Your first-mortgage rate is lower than today’s rates, and you want to keep it.
  • The money goes out in stages, or the final amount is uncertain.
  • A payment that moves with the prime rate fits your budget.
  • Moving within a few years is likely, so upfront costs and any cancellation fee matter more.

If the cash will pay off other balances, see how to use home equity to pay off debt.

Home equity loan vs cash out refinance

A home equity loan is the third option: a fixed-rate lump sum on a second lien. Like a HELOC, it leaves your first mortgage alone, so the same arithmetic applies. The fixed payment removes the rate risk, but more money later means a new loan. For details, see how home equity loan rates are set and the HELOC vs home equity loan comparison.

If you have a USDA loan

A USDA loan cannot be refinanced with cash out inside the USDA program, so ask your lender whether a second lien such as a HELOC is allowed on your loan.

Costs and risks that apply to both

  • Your home is the collateral. “If you fall behind or can’t repay the loan on schedule, you could lose your home,” the CFPB warns about HELOCs. That risk applies to both sides of the cash out refinance vs HELOC choice.
  • Closing costs and fees. Cash-out refinance closing costs are generally higher, according to the CFPB, while HELOC fees vary by plan.
  • Right to cancel. On a loan secured by your principal residence, you generally have until midnight of the third business day after the latest of closing, getting the cancellation notice and getting the final disclosures to cancel (12 CFR 1026.15 and 1026.23). If you refinance with your current lender, the right covers only the new money (1026.23(f)(2)). Saturdays count as business days for this rule, but Sundays and federal holidays do not, so ask your lender how the date is counted.

Taxes work the same way for both

IRS Publication 936 (2025) says interest on home equity loans and lines of credit is deductible “only if the borrowed funds are used to buy, build, or substantially improve the taxpayer’s home that secures the loan.” Similarly, refinanced debt counts as home acquisition debt only up to the old balance, and extra cash used for anything else does not count.

As a result, interest on cash used for debt payoff, tuition or a car is not deductible as home mortgage interest with either product. You also have to itemize on Schedule A, and the limit for newer debt is $750,000 of total mortgage debt ($375,000 if married filing separately). Check the current Pub. 936 or ask a tax professional first.

As a next step, get a cash-out refinance Loan Estimate and a HELOC offer with its fee list, then run both through the arithmetic above.

Cash out refinance vs HELOC FAQ

Should I get a cash out refinance or HELOC?

It depends mostly on your first-mortgage rate, how much you need and how much rate risk you can carry. If your rate is well below today’s rates, a HELOC can cost less interest, as the worked example shows. If your rate is at or above today’s rates, a cash-out refinance may cost no more.

What is the difference between a cash-out refinance and a HELOC?

A cash-out refinance replaces your first mortgage with a bigger loan and pays you the difference, so you keep one payment. A HELOC is a separate second loan, usually at a variable rate, that you draw on as needed.

Is a HELOC better than refinancing?

Not in general. A HELOC can cost less when your first-mortgage rate is below today’s rates, because only the new money gets a new rate. Otherwise, a cash-out refinance can be the cheaper path.

Does a HELOC refinance your mortgage?

No. A HELOC is a second loan, so your first mortgage keeps its rate, payment and term, and you make a separate HELOC payment.

Do cash-out refinances have higher closing costs than HELOCs?

The CFPB says cash-out refinance closing costs are “generally higher.” However, HELOC fees vary by plan and can include annual and cancellation fees, so ask each lender for the full list.

What is the difference between a home equity loan and a cash-out refinance?

A home equity loan is a fixed-rate lump sum on a second lien, and your first mortgage stays as it is. A cash-out refinance replaces your first mortgage with a new, larger loan at a new rate.