On this page
- How to compare mortgage lenders in five steps
- Get ready before you compare mortgage lenders
- Where to find lenders to compare
- Mortgage broker or direct lender
- Shop in a short window so credit checks count once
- How to compare Loan Estimates side by side
- How to choose a loan officer
- Frequently asked questions
- Compare mortgage lenders with three Loan Estimates
To compare mortgage lenders, ask at least three of them for a Loan Estimate on the same loan, on the same day, and read the forms side by side. Page 1 shows the rate and payment, page 2 the origination charges and lender credits, and page 3 the APR, total interest percentage and five-year cost. Also, mortgage credit checks within the scoring window count as one inquiry.
Shopping can pay off. Freddie Mac’s 2023 research found that in October and November 2022, two rate quotes could have saved as much as $600 a year, and four or more quotes more than $1,200. That was a simulation for one narrow borrower profile, though, so it shows how much offers can differ and promises nothing. Even so, a 2015 CFPB report on buyers who closed in 2013 found that almost half seriously considered only one lender or broker.
How to compare mortgage lenders in five steps
- Get ready. Check your credit report, and pick a loan type, term and down payment.
- Build a short list. Include at least three lenders, and add a broker if you like.
- Apply in a tight window, so the credit checks count as one inquiry.
- Line up the Loan Estimates for the same loan and compare the five-year cost, after any lender credit, as well as the rate.
- Choose the person as well as the company, then tell your pick you want to proceed.
For context, Freddie Mac’s weekly survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% on November 12, 2026, up from 6.24% a year earlier. The survey is an average, so the rate you are offered can differ by lender and by borrower.
Get ready before you compare mortgage lenders
First, pull your credit reports. According to the FTC, all three bureaus let you check your report from each once a week for free at AnnualCreditReport.com. Checking your own report does not affect your scores, so fix any errors before a lender pulls your credit.
Next, decide what you are shopping for: the loan type (conventional, FHA, VA or USDA), the term, and a fixed or adjustable rate. A first-time buyer’s guide can help. Also, settle on a down payment. Each program sets a minimum, and a lender’s own rules can be higher, as the conventional loan down payment guide explains.
Then get a mortgage pre-approval. In fact, the CFPB says you can get multiple preapprovals and Loan Estimates within the same credit-check window.
Where to find lenders to compare
The CFPB suggests you start with an internet search. After that, contact banks, credit unions, other lenders and mortgage brokers.
Word of mouth helps as well. For example, ask friends and family who bought or refinanced recently which loan officer they would use again. Your agent will have names too, so add lenders to your questions to ask a real estate agent. Even so, test every referral the same way.
Before you apply, look up each company and loan officer on NMLS Consumer Access. This free service confirms whether a mortgage company or professional is authorized to do business in your state. You can search by name, company, location or NMLS ID.
Mortgage broker or direct lender
Under federal rules, a mortgage broker is any loan originator who is not an employee of the lender that makes the loan. In contrast, a lender’s loan officer works for that lender and can offer only its loans. A broker can send one application to several lenders it works with. Page 3 of the Loan Estimate lists each one’s NMLS ID for you to check.
| Lender’s loan officer | Mortgage broker | |
|---|---|---|
| Who they work for | The lender that funds your loan | Their own firm, which works with outside lenders |
| Who pays them | The lender, as their employer | You or the lender, never both |
| Where the pay shows | Lender fees appear under Origination Charges on page 2 | Pay from you appears under Origination Charges; lender-paid pay is built into the rate and shows on the Closing Disclosure |
| Steering rule | Pay cannot depend on the rate or other loan terms, and no steering to a loan for higher pay unless it is in your interest | Same pay and steering rules |
How mortgage brokers are paid
A broker can be paid by you or by the lender, not both. Under 12 CFR 1026.36, pay cannot be tied to the rate or other loan terms. However, it can be a fixed percentage of the loan amount.
So brokers are not free. A fee you pay directly shows up in Origination Charges on page 2. By contrast, lender-paid pay comes through the interest rate, so it is itemized only on the Closing Disclosure. For that reason, judge a broker’s offer on rate and costs together, and ask in writing who pays the broker, how much, and whether it changes your rate.
Is a mortgage broker worth it?
It depends on your file and on the offers. A broker can help when you want one application priced at several lenders. On the other hand, a direct lender can suit you if you already bank there or want one company from application to closing.
No rule says brokers get better rates, and none says lenders do, so ask both. In addition, ask the broker to show you the loan with the lowest rate, the lowest rate without risky features, and the lowest total of points and origination fees. A loan originator who gets options from a significant number of the lenders it regularly works with, and shows you those three loans, falls within a federal safe harbor against steering.
First-time buyers do not need a broker. Instead, get one broker’s Loan Estimate and two from direct lenders, then compare mortgage lenders and brokers on the same form.
Shop in a short window so credit checks count once
Lenders check your credit as part of an application. According to the CFPB, mortgage credit checks within a 45-day window are recorded as a single inquiry, which has a small negative effect. So you can compare mortgage lenders without extra credit damage, as long as the last check falls within 45 days of the first.
To be safe, get your applications in within about 14 days, because older scoring versions use a shorter window. Meanwhile, avoid applying for a credit card or car loan, since those count as separate inquiries.
How to compare Loan Estimates side by side
Lenders use the same three-page Loan Estimate for most mortgages, which makes it the best tool to compare mortgage lenders. Under Regulation Z, a lender must deliver it within three business days of your application. To get one, you share six items: name, income, Social Security number, property address, estimated value and loan amount. You do not need a signed purchase contract.
To make the offers match, the CFPB tells borrowers to ask each lender for the same kind of loan with the same features. That means the same loan amount, term, rate type and down payment, ideally requested on the same day.
| What to compare | Where it is on the Loan Estimate |
|---|---|
| Interest rate and whether it is locked | Page 1, Loan Terms and the top of the page |
| Monthly principal and interest | Page 1, Loan Terms |
| Risky features (prepayment penalty, balloon payment, increases after closing) | Page 1, Loan Terms |
| Origination charges, including points | Page 2, Section A |
| Services you cannot shop for | Page 2, Section B |
| Services you can shop for | Page 2, Section C |
| Lender credits | Page 2, Section J |
| In 5 Years, APR and Total Interest Percentage | Page 3, Comparisons |
| Lender, broker and loan officer NMLS IDs | Page 3, Additional Information |
Page 1: rate, payment, lock and risky features
Start with the interest rate and the monthly principal and interest. Then check the top of page 1 to see whether the rate is locked, and until when. An unlocked rate can change at any time, so a locked offer and a floating offer are not a true match.
Next, read the yes-or-no lines under Loan Terms. If the rate or payment can rise after closing, or the loan has a prepayment penalty or balloon payment, ask why, or request an estimate without that feature.
Page 2: origination charges, third-party services and lender credits
Section A lists origination charges, which you pay the lender and any broker to make the loan. The CFPB says the total matters most, because some lenders itemize more than others. Also, ask each lender whether it will lower any loan origination fee or other origination charge. Points to lower the rate sit on their own line, and the mortgage discount points guide explains whether they pay off.
Section B lists services the lender picks, such as the appraisal, so compare that subtotal across lenders. By contrast, Section C lists services you can shop for, like title work, which are part of your closing costs. Finally, check Section J for lender credits. A credit lowers your closing costs, but you may pay a higher rate in exchange.
Page 3: APR, total interest percentage and five-year cost
The Comparisons table on page 3 even says, “Use these measures to compare this loan with other loans.” The APR folds points, broker fees and other charges into a yearly rate, as the APR vs. interest rate guide explains. However, an adjustable-rate loan’s APR does not reflect the highest rate it can reach.
“In 5 Years” shows what you will have paid in principal, interest, mortgage insurance and loan costs over 60 months. That figure counts loan costs from Sections A to C but not the lender credit in Section J, so subtract any lender credit yourself before you compare two offers. Meanwhile, the Total Interest Percentage shows lifetime interest as a share of the loan amount. Together with your own tally of costs and credits, they show whether a lower rate is worth its upfront cost.
Example: lower rate or lower fees
As an illustration with invented numbers, say two lenders quote the same $300,000, 30-year fixed purchase loan. The figures cover principal and interest only, with no taxes, insurance or mortgage insurance, and equal third-party costs.
| Offer A | Offer B | |
|---|---|---|
| Example rate | 6.50% | 6.75% |
| Points | 1 point ($3,000) | None |
| Other origination charges | $1,500 | $1,500 |
| Lender credit | None | $1,500 |
| Net lender cost at closing | $4,500 | $0 |
| Monthly principal and interest | $1,896.20 | $1,945.79 |
| Lender cost plus 60 payments | $118,272.00 | $116,747.40 |
The form’s In 5 Years line would not subtract Offer B’s $1,500 credit, so tally the credit yourself, as this table does. Offer A has the lower rate and a payment about $50 lower. Still, after five years, Offer B costs about $1,525 less in lender charges and payments. Offer A pays down about $800 more principal in that time, which narrows the gap but does not close it. So a buyer who expects to sell or refinance within five years would favor B here, while a longer stay can favor A.
A Loan Estimate is not an approval, and you have not committed to that lender. Once you say you want to proceed, though, a lender can charge fees such as an application or appraisal fee. For that reason, tell only your final pick that you intend to proceed.
How to choose a loan officer
The person handling your file can matter as much as the price. So watch how each candidate handles your Loan Estimate request, because their speed and clarity now are a useful clue to how they will handle your file later.
Questions to ask a loan officer
- How long have you originated loans, and how long have you been with this company?
- Who pays you on this loan, and how much?
- When do you usually respond, and who covers when you are out?
- Who else will work on my file?
- What could change the numbers on this Loan Estimate before closing?
- Is my rate locked, for how long, and what does an extension cost? The mortgage rate lock guide covers timing.
Red flags
- A request for money before you get a Loan Estimate, other than a credit report fee. The CFPB says that is against the law.
- A push toward a different loan than you asked for, without a clear reason. In that case, ask for Loan Estimates for both.
- A request to sign a form with blank spaces.
- A quote far below every other, with no explanation. Ask whether it includes points or a lock.
- A closing date much faster than any other lender promises, with no explanation.
- Any comment that discourages you from applying because of a protected trait.
What a lender may and may not ask
Questions about your income, job, accounts, debts and credit history are normal. However, the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and Regulation B bar discrimination based on race, color, religion, national origin, sex, marital status or age (if you can sign a contract). The list also covers receiving public assistance income and exercising consumer credit rights in good faith.
A lender generally may not ask your race, color, religion, national origin or sex. The main exception is the government monitoring section on an application to buy or refinance your primary home, which you do not have to answer. If you think a lender treated you unfairly, file a complaint with the CFPB or HUD’s Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity.
Frequently asked questions
Does shopping for a mortgage hurt my credit?
Not much, if you shop in a tight window. The CFPB says mortgage credit checks within 45 days count as one inquiry. Because older scoring versions use 14 days, aim to finish within about two weeks.
How many lenders should I compare?
The CFPB suggests Loan Estimates from at least three lenders. Freddie Mac’s 2023 research also found that more quotes meant larger potential savings in late 2022. That is a past result for one borrower profile, so your savings could be larger, smaller or zero.
Is a mortgage broker worth it?
A broker is worth it if they bring you a better total offer than the lenders you contact yourself. To find out, compare a broker’s Loan Estimate with direct lenders’ estimates for the same loan.
How much does a mortgage broker cost?
Broker pay varies and can be a fixed percentage of the loan amount, paid by you or by the lender through the rate, never both. Ask the broker for the amount in writing.
How do I find a good loan officer?
Ask people who closed recently whom they would use again, then confirm the loan officer on NMLS Consumer Access. After that, compare how quickly and clearly each one handles the same Loan Estimate request.
Why do mortgage rates vary by lender?
Each lender sets its own pricing and rules. A 2015 CFPB release noted that rates vary “even for the same consumer and for loans with otherwise identical product features.” Similarly, Freddie Mac’s 2023 research measured the spread of rates on similar same-day applications (one standard deviation) at about 0.5 percentage point in October and November 2022.
Compare mortgage lenders with three Loan Estimates
Pick three lenders this week, with a broker among them if you like, and ask each for the same loan in the same short window. Then compare mortgage lenders side by side, starting with the five-year cost on page 3 (less any lender credit) and the origination charges on page 2. Then choose the offer and the loan officer you trust.