On this page
You can often get a unique property mortgage on a log home, dome home, earth-sheltered home or barn conversion. In fact, Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide says loans on earth houses, geodesic domes and log houses are eligible when the appraiser can support the value. Freddie Mac’s appraisal rules name log, berm, geodesic dome and barn-conversion homes, and FHA’s rules name log, earth-sheltered and dome houses. What decides your loan is the appraisal, whether the home is legal, safe and sound, and whether it could sell later.
A houseboat is not real estate under Fannie Mae’s rules, and a tiny home on wheels often is not either. As a result, these usually need a different kind of loan.
“Unconventional” or “non-conforming” can describe a loan that falls outside agency rules, and our non-conforming loans guide covers those. This article, by contrast, covers the property: a home that is unusual for its market.
Why Financing Unique Properties Is Harder
A lender’s main protection is the home itself. If the borrower stops paying, the lender has to sell it. So the lender wants proof that the home is worth the loan amount and that buyers would want it later.
Both points are harder to prove for a unique home. The usual way to value a house is to compare it with similar homes that sold nearby. However, a dome house in a town of ranch homes may have no true match. As a result, the appraiser has less data and the lender has less certainty.
Resale is the second worry. A home with fewer likely buyers may take longer to sell, and that raises the lender’s risk if it ever has to foreclose.
Freddie Mac’s Guide, Section 5605.7, says there may be “no similar comparable sales for a subject property because of the uniqueness of the subject property or other conditions.” Similarly, Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide, B4-1.3-08, plans for “a shortage of truly comparable sales.” Both topics then explain how the appraiser should handle the gap, and neither tells lenders to turn these homes down.
How an Appraiser Values a Home With No Comparable Sales
An appraisal for a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan must include at least three closed comparable sales, often called comps. What a home appraisal costs varies by home and area. When nearby sales are not similar, the rules give the appraiser several tools:
- Farther sales. The appraiser may use sales from outside the home’s market area. In that case, the report must explain why.
- Older sales. Both agencies say comps should have closed within the last 12 months. Even so, older sales may be used with an explanation.
- Less similar sales. Fannie Mae B4-1.3-08 accepts properties that are “not truly comparable” if the appraiser “adequately documents the analysis and explains why they were used.”
- Large adjustments. The appraiser adjusts each comp’s price for its differences from your home. Freddie Mac “does not have limitations on gross or net adjustment percentages,” according to Section 5605.7.
- Cost approach as support. This method estimates the cost to build the home today, minus wear, plus the land. Freddie Mac Section 5605.8 says it “may be appropriate” for barndominiums, berm homes, log homes and geodesic domes. Still, Freddie Mac does not accept an appraisal that relies only on the cost approach (outside its HeritageOne program).
FHA’s extra condition for nonstandard styles
Under “Nonstandard House Styles” in HUD Handbook 4000.1, the appraiser must comment that the home “appears structurally sound and readily marketable.” The appraiser must also show it sits in “an area of other similar types of construction.”
Unique property mortgage rules by agency
| Rule | Freddie Mac | Fannie Mae | FHA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unique home types named | Barndominiums, “shouses,” berm, log and geodesic dome homes (5605.8) | Earth houses, geodesic domes and log houses, eligible if the appraiser can support the value (B4-1.3-05) | Log, earth-sheltered, dome and low-ceiling houses (4000.1, II.D.3) |
| Comparable sales | At least three; farther, older or adjusted sales allowed with commentary (5605.7) | At least three; farther, older or less similar sales allowed with an explanation (B4-1.3-08) | Appraiser must “apply appropriate techniques” for these homes |
| Extra condition | Cost approach can support the sales comparison but cannot replace it | Home must be residential, safe, sound, legal and fit for year-round use (B2-3-01) | Appraiser must call the home sound and readily marketable, near similar homes |
These are rules the lender and appraiser must follow, and they do not promise anyone a unique property mortgage. Also, a lender may add stricter rules of its own, called overlays. For that reason, one lender may say no while another says yes.
What the Agencies Say About Each Home Type
Here is how the rules apply to each style.
Log home mortgage
FHA, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae all name log homes. Ideally, the appraiser finds recent sales of other log homes nearby. Without them, the appraiser may use adjusted sales of other homes, and the cost approach can back up those adjustments.
Earth-sheltered home loan
FHA calls these “earth sheltered housing,” Fannie Mae says “earth houses,” and Freddie Mac says “berm homes.” Fannie Mae calls loans on them eligible when the appraiser has adequate information to support a reliable value. However, the home is not acceptable when there is no evidence of market acceptance. Fannie Mae’s general rules also apply: the home must be safe, sound, structurally secure and suitable for year-round use.
Dome home financing
FHA lists “dome houses,” Fannie Mae lists “geodesic domes,” and Freddie Mac lists “geodesic dome dwellings.” Under FHA’s rule, a dome near other similar construction has an easier path than a lone dome among ranch houses.
Barndominium loan
Freddie Mac is the only one of the three that uses the word. It lists barn conversions (“barndominiums”) and “shouses,” which combine living space with a shop. FHA’s handbook does not use the term, and the Fannie Mae Selling Guide topics on property eligibility and appraisals do not either. Even so, a barndominium with a kitchen, bath, heat and finished living space is more likely to be judged a residential home than a farm building.
Land use matters too. Fannie Mae does not buy loans on agricultural properties such as farms or ranches. Meanwhile, Freddie Mac Section 5605.6 says a home in a farming area may be eligible if the appraiser decides it is residential. Therefore, a barndominium on acreage with a working farm operation may draw questions.
For a new build, Fannie Mae bars the appraiser from creating a comp by adding a vacant land sale to a home’s build price. Such deals can only serve as extra support. If you plan to buy the lot first, read how land loans differ from home mortgages.
Tiny house mortgage
The foundation decides most of it. A tiny home on a permanent foundation, built to local code on land you own, is a small house. FHA “does not have a minimum size requirement” for one- to four-family homes, and Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide (B4-1.3-05) sets none for site-built homes either. However, the appraiser still needs comparable sales of similar size. In addition, FHA requires basic living features, such as a bathroom, a kitchen, heat and hot water.
A tiny home on wheels is different. It is often registered as a trailer or RV, and then it may not count as real estate. Unless it carries a HUD label and has at least 400 square feet, it also does not meet the manufactured home rules. As general guidance, buyers of these homes often use a personal loan or an RV loan, so ask the lender how it treats the home.
Converted church, school or firehouse
Fannie Mae requires a home that is residential in nature, with a legal or legal non-conforming use. In other words, zoning decides much of the answer.
Manufactured homes
Manufactured homes follow their own rules, including a HUD label, a permanent chassis and foundation, and at least 400 square feet under both FHA and Fannie Mae. For details, see the FHA manufactured home guidelines and manufactured home age requirements.
Ways to Get a Unique Property Mortgage If a Lender Says No
These are options to ask about, and none comes with a guarantee.
- Another lender. Overlays differ by lender. On the first call, ask which property types they decline.
- Portfolio lender. A local bank or credit union that keeps its loans sets its own rules. It may be more flexible.
- Bigger down payment. More of your own money lowers the lender’s risk, so ask whether it changes the answer.
- Better-documented appraisal. Ask for an appraiser who knows the home style. The report should explain any farther, older or adjusted sales. If the appraisal still comes in low, see what to do after a low appraisal.
- Construction or renovation loan. If you are building the home or converting a barn, a construction-to-permanent loan or a renovation loan may fit. Our home improvement loans guide covers renovation options.
- Cash. Paying cash removes the lender from the purchase, and you could refinance later if the home appraises. Even so, get an appraisal first so you know the home’s value. Read more on paying cash for a home.
Before You Make an Offer on a Unique Home
Use this checklist before you apply for a unique property mortgage or sign a contract:
- Call a lender first. Describe the home and ask whether the lender finances that property type, and under which loan program.
- Check the basics. Fannie Mae B2-3-01 requires a residential, safe and sound home with a legal use. It also needs road access that meets local standards, utilities that meet community standards and year-round use.
- Verify zoning and permits. This matters most for a conversion or a tiny home.
- Protect yourself in the contract. Make the offer subject to financing and the appraisal, so you can back out if either falls short.
- Get an insurance quote. Do this before your contingency period ends.
- Plan your time in the home. A unique home may take longer to sell, so it tends to suit a buyer who plans to stay.
Above all, ask a lender whether it finances this kind of home before you make an offer.
For Sellers of Unique Homes
Expect a smaller pool of buyers and a sale that may take longer. In addition, a buyer’s unique property mortgage depends on an appraisal that may come in below your price. To help, share records of build costs, upgrades and any nearby sales of similar homes with your agent. Finally, cash buyers and buyers with large down payments may close more easily.
Unique Property Mortgage FAQ
Can you get a mortgage on a unique property?
Often, yes. Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and FHA all name log and dome homes in their appraisal rules, as well as earth-sheltered (earth or berm) homes. Approval still depends on the appraisal, the home’s condition and legal use, and the lender’s own rules.
Does FHA finance log, dome or earth-sheltered homes?
Yes, in principle. HUD Handbook 4000.1 lists them as nonstandard house styles. The appraiser must comment that the home appears structurally sound and readily marketable, and must show similar homes in the area.
Can I get a loan for a barndominium?
Possibly. Freddie Mac’s appraisal rules name barndominiums and allow the cost approach as support. Ask lenders directly, because acreage and any farm use can affect eligibility.
Can you get a mortgage on a tiny house?
On a permanent foundation and land you own, it can qualify as a small house, and FHA has no minimum size. On wheels, however, it often may not count as real estate, so it usually needs a different kind of loan.
What if my appraisal comes in low on a unique home?
First, ask the lender how to request a review with better comparable sales. Otherwise, you can renegotiate the price or bring more cash to closing. Our low appraisal guide walks through each option.