On this page
What compensating factors are
A compensating factor is a strength in your file that a lender can point to when one number, usually your debt-to-income ratio, is higher than the standard limit. Compensating factors matter mainly when a loan is manually underwritten. FHA has a fixed list of them, while automated approval systems can weigh the same strengths without a list.
Manual underwriting means a person reviews your file against the program’s written rules instead of relying on an automated approval. Compensating factors are the documented reasons an underwriter uses to accept ratios above the base limit, and each program defines them its own way.
When a lender uses compensating factors
Many loans start in an automated underwriting system: FHA’s TOTAL Mortgage Scorecard, Fannie Mae’s Desktop Underwriter (DU) or USDA’s Guaranteed Underwriting System (GUS). Our guide to mortgage underwriting explains that process. When TOTAL returns an Accept on an FHA loan, the lender does not pick factors from HUD’s list to justify your ratios.
HUD requires a manual underwrite when TOTAL issues a Refer, or when the file is downgraded to manual underwriting. HUD forces that downgrade in some cases, such as a recent bankruptcy or foreclosure. That is when FHA compensating factors come into play, which is why borrowers hear the term most on FHA loans.
Because ratio limits vary by program, see the percentage of income lenders allow for a mortgage. A lender can also set stricter rules of its own, called overlays, than any program requires.
FHA compensating factors
FHA’s rules sit in HUD Handbook 4000.1, section II.A.5.d.viii, which took effect in its current version on November 10, 2026. The matrix pairs your credit score (for a joint loan, the lowest borrower’s decision score) with two ratios. The first is your total mortgage payment as a share of effective income (the income the lender can count). The second adds all your other monthly debts.
HUD’s total mortgage payment includes principal, interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance and HOA dues, among other items. Here is the manual underwriting matrix as of November 2026:
| Credit score | Maximum ratios | Compensating factors required |
|---|---|---|
| 500–579 or no score | 31/43 | None accepted to go higher. An energy efficient home may use 33/45. |
| 580 or higher | 31/43 | None required. An energy efficient home may use 33/45. |
| 580 or higher | 37/47 | One of: cash reserves, minimal increase in housing payment, or residual income |
| 580 or higher | 40/40 | No discretionary debt |
| 580 or higher | 40/50 | Two of: cash reserves, minimal increase in housing payment, significant additional income, or residual income |
The 40/50 tier needs a 580 or higher score and two factors. Our FHA loan requirements page covers the rest of the program’s rules.
Say a buyer with a 640 score has ratios of 35/46 on a manual underwrite. That falls in the 37/47 tier, so the lender needs one factor from that row.
Cash reserves
Your reserves must equal at least three total monthly mortgage payments for a one- or two-unit home, or six for a three- or four-unit home. HUD counts reserves as your total assets minus the funds needed to close, gifts, borrowed funds, and cash-out proceeds or other cash you receive at closing. For example, with a $2,000 total payment on a single-family home, you would need at least $6,000 of your own money left after closing.
Minimal increase in housing payment
Your new total mortgage payment can be no more than $100 or 5% above your current total housing payment (rent or mortgage), whichever is less. You also need a documented 12-month housing history with no more than one 30-day late payment. For instance, with rent of $1,800, 5% is $90, so the new payment can reach $1,890. However, if you live rent-free today, the lender cannot cite this factor.
No discretionary debt
This factor alone allows 40/40. To qualify, your housing payment must be the only open account with a balance you do not pay off each month. In addition, your credit report must show credit lines in your own name open for at least six months, and you must document paying them in full monthly for those six months. Accounts where you are only an authorized user do not count.
Significant additional income
Overtime, bonuses, or part-time or seasonal income that the lender did not count in your effective income can serve as a factor. The lender must verify you have received it for at least one year and that it will likely continue. If counted, it must be enough to bring your ratios down to 37/47 or lower. Income from anyone not on the loan, such as a non-borrowing spouse, does not count. Also, this factor appears only in the 40/50 tier, paired with another factor.
Residual income
Residual income is the money left each month after taxes, your total mortgage payment and debts, estimated maintenance and utilities, and job costs such as child care. FHA borrows VA’s Table of Residual Incomes, so your residual income must meet VA’s figure for your loan amount, household size and region. Every household member counts toward household size, with a narrow exception.
Energy efficient homes
A qualifying home allows stretch ratios of 33/45, even with a score below 580. New construction must meet the higher of HUD’s adopted energy code or the local code. An existing home needs a Home Energy Score of 6 or higher, or improvements, completed before closing or financed through an FHA rehab or energy program, that raise it to 6. This factor differs from the Energy Efficient Mortgage (EEM), a separate FHA program.
If your lender has said you need FHA compensating factors, compare a few lenders that manually underwrite FHA loans.
VA compensating factors and residual income
VA weighs residual income first. Its Lenders Handbook, VA Pamphlet 26-7, chapter 4, calls the debt-to-income ratio “a guide” that is “secondary to the residual income.” VA treats its minimum residual incomes as a guide too, weighed with all of your other credit factors.
A ratio above 41% calls for close scrutiny, unless the higher ratio comes solely from tax-free income or your residual income beats the guideline by at least 20%. When a lender closes a loan automatically above 41%, the file must hold a statement signed by the underwriter’s supervisor that lists the compensating factors, unless residual income beats the guideline by at least 20%. Learn more about the program in our VA home loan guide.
VA’s list of compensating factors is open-ended. It includes:
- Excellent credit history
- Conservative use of consumer credit
- Minimal consumer debt
- Long-term employment
- Significant liquid assets
- A sizable down payment
- Equity in a refinance
- Little or no increase in shelter expense
- Military benefits
- Satisfactory homeownership experience
- High residual income
- A low debt-to-income ratio
- Tax credits for child care
- Tax benefits of homeownership
VA adds two rules. First, compensating factors “cannot be used to compensate for unsatisfactory credit.” Second, simply meeting a basic requirement, such as having enough assets to close, is not a factor. A factor should also offset the actual weakness: significant liquid assets can offset a residual income shortfall, whereas long-term employment cannot.
USDA debt ratio waivers
USDA’s standard limits are 29% for the housing payment and 41% for total debt (7 CFR 3555.151(h)). A GUS Accept needs no waiver. For a GUS Refer, Refer with Caution or manual loan, the lender can request a debt ratio waiver up to 32% and 44%, per USDA Handbook HB-1-3555, section 11.3.
For a purchase, every applicant needs a validated credit score of 680 or higher. In addition, the lender must document at least one of these factors:
- Savings or reserves left after closing of at least three months of the new payment (cash on hand does not count)
- Two years of continuous employment with the current primary employer for every employed applicant (not for self-employed applicants)
- A new payment no more than $100 or 5% above the verified housing cost of the past 12 months, whichever is less, with no more than one 30-day late payment
- An energy efficient home that meets the International Energy Conservation Code
USDA approves the waiver through its Conditional Commitment.
Fannie Mae and conventional loans
Fannie Mae does not publish a compensating factors list. Instead, its manual underwriting rules use a “comprehensive risk assessment” (Selling Guide B3-1-01). That review weighs your equity investment, credit history, liquid reserves, reliable recurring income and the combined effect of those risks.
For a manually underwritten loan, Selling Guide B3-6-02 caps total DTI at 36% of stable monthly income. The cap can rise to 45% if you meet the credit score and reserve requirements in Fannie Mae’s Eligibility Matrix. The matrix sets a minimum credit score and minimum reserves for each loan type, loan-to-value ratio and ratio level, so check the row for your loan.
For a loan run through DU, the maximum DTI is 50%. DU can weigh a few strengths as offsets for other risks (B3-2-03):
- A lower loan-to-value (LTV) ratio
- More liquid reserves
- On some loans, 12 months of rent payments shown on a credit report or an asset verification report
How to get compensating factors ready in your file
Several compensating factors depend on a record you build over months, so start early.
- Reserves: Keep it in your own accounts, with statements for the period your lender asks for. Gifts and borrowed funds do not count as FHA reserves.
- Extra income: Collect pay stubs and W-2s that show at least a year of overtime, bonus or part-time pay.
- Other debts: For the no-discretionary-debt factor, your housing payment must be the only account with a balance you do not pay off each month. Pay every card in full for at least six months, and note that an open auto, student or personal loan rules this factor out.
- Housing cost: Pay rent on time for 12 months, and keep your new payment close to what you pay now. If your ratios still miss, our guide to a mortgage denial covers your next options. Otherwise, compare lenders that manually underwrite your loan type.
Compensating factors FAQ
What are compensating factors for a mortgage?
They are documented strengths, such as cash reserves, that let an underwriter approve ratios above the standard limit. Each program sets its own rules for manually underwritten loans.
What are the FHA compensating factors?
HUD lists six: cash reserves, minimal increase in housing payment, no discretionary debt, significant additional income, residual income and an energy efficient home.
How many compensating factors do I need?
On an FHA manual underwrite with a 580 or higher score, you need none at 31/43, one at 37/47 and two at 40/50. No discretionary debt alone allows 40/40. Below 580, factors cannot raise your ratios past 31/43 (33/45 for an energy efficient home).
Does VA use compensating factors?
Yes. However, VA weighs residual income first and treats the 41% debt-to-income ratio as a guide. Above 41%, VA calls for close scrutiny. When a lender closes the loan automatically, the file needs a supervisor’s signed statement listing the compensating factors, unless residual income beats the guideline by 20%.
Can compensating factors make up for a low credit score?
No. FHA does not accept factors to raise ratios when the score is below 580, and VA says they cannot offset unsatisfactory credit. Likewise, USDA requires a 680 score for its debt ratio waiver.