On this page
Rent-to-own means you rent a home now with a right, or sometimes a duty, to buy it later. The terms are in the contract, so read whether you can buy or must buy. If you do not buy, you can lose your option fee and your rent credits. The seller may also owe a mortgage on the home, so it may not be theirs free and clear. Before you sign, have a lawyer read the contract and talk to a HUD-approved housing counselor.
A Minnesota legal-aid fact sheet warns that “many people lose money and time” in these deals, and under a contract for deed the seller may move to evict quickly. If you are still deciding whether to buy at all, start with our rent vs. buy guide.
What is rent-to-own?
LawHelpMN’s fact sheet puts it simply: “Renting to own usually means renting now, with an option to buy later.” Until the final purchase, you are still a tenant, and the seller is still your landlord.
Contracts differ in one big way. Some agreements give you an option, so you can buy but do not have to. Others may bind you to buy. Ads may say “lease option” or “lease purchase,” but the contract’s wording decides, so read whether you can buy or must buy.
A contract for deed is a different product
A contract for deed works differently, although it can come up in the same kind of deal. LawHelpMN covers both in one fact sheet. According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), the seller keeps legal title until you make every payment. Meanwhile, you act as the owner from the start. In a typical contract for deed, the CFPB says, the buyer pays the property taxes, insurance, repairs and maintenance.
The CFPB says some contracts for deed can lead to ownership, “but most carry risks.” Because the seller acts as the lender, it is a form of seller financing.
How rent to own homes work
Look for these parts in a rent-to-own contract:
- Monthly rent: You pay rent for the lease term, as any tenant would.
- An up-front payment: Many agreements ask for a payment at signing, often called a down payment or option fee. LawHelpMN notes this differs from a security deposit, which you can usually get back.
- A rent credit, or none: Some contracts count part of each payment toward the price. Others count nothing.
- A price and a date: The contract should state the sale price, when the sale happens, and how. That could be a mortgage you get on your own or a contract for deed with the seller.
- Who handles what: Repairs, taxes and insurance depend on the contract and on state law.
At the end, you either buy the home, which may need a mortgage, or walk away. If you walk away, you may lose the up-front payment and any credits.
Why rent-to-own is bad: the risks
You can lose the money you paid toward buying
LawHelpMN says “you may not get the down payment back if you do not buy the home.” It also lists two warning signs. One is when “only a tiny amount or none of the payments are counted toward buying the house.” The other is when you are “only paying for the right (‘option’) to buy the house.” By the time that right comes up, your situation may have changed.
The seller may not own the home free and clear
A seller might not own the home, or might owe a mortgage on it. LawHelpMN advises checking the county recorder for both. It warns, “If the mortgage is not paid you can end up losing the home.” For contracts for deed, the CFPB adds that a seller may fail to mention a lien or may refuse to hand over the deed.
Some offers are scams
According to LawHelpMN, some landlords “don’t really plan to sell the home.” Instead, they use the agreement to get more money from tenants or to get tenants to work on the home.
You may be asked to pay for repairs
Some landlords try to make the buyer pay for repairs. The Minnesota fact sheet says this is illegal under a Minnesota rent-to-own deal, since you are a tenant with a tenant’s rights. State law varies, so check the rules where the home is.
A missed payment can lead to eviction
Under a lease with an option to buy, you are a tenant, and state landlord-tenant law applies. So a missed rent payment can still lead to eviction. Under a contract for deed, the CFPB says the seller “often tries to start eviction right away” after a missed payment, an unpaid balloon payment, or unpaid taxes or maintenance. The seller may also try to keep the money and work you put in.
You may not get a mortgage at the end
If the sale needs a mortgage, you have to qualify for one at the end. LawHelpMN advises talking to a bank “to see if you can get one before you sign.” For a contract for deed with a balloon payment, it warns that if you cannot get a mortgage, “you will lose the house and all the money you have paid.”
Do rent credits count toward a mortgage?
Sometimes, but only part of what you paid may count. Lenders follow the rules of the loan program. Fannie Mae and FHA, for example, credit only the rent you paid above market rent.
Fannie Mae’s rule
Under the Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B3-4.3-12, a rent credit can go toward the down payment. However, “the credit may be no more than the difference between the market rent and the actual rent paid.” The appraiser sets the market rent. The lender also needs a lease with an option to purchase showing an original term of at least 12 months, the monthly rent and the monthly credit. It needs proof of each payment, too, such as canceled checks or bank statements.
FHA’s rule
HUD Handbook 4000.1, section II.A.4.d.iii(T), defines rent credits as “the amount of the rental payment that exceeds the Appraiser’s estimate of fair market rent.” The lender needs the agreement, the appraiser’s market rent estimate and evidence of your payments.
An example of how the limit works
Say an appraiser sets market rent at $1,500 a month. Your lease charges $1,700 and calls $300 of it a monthly “rent credit.” Under these rules, only $200 a month can count, because that is what you paid above market. After 24 months, the usable credit would be up to $4,800, even though the contract promised $7,200. If your rent equals market rent, no credit counts.
The up-front option fee is a separate question. Ask a lender before you sign whether your credits and fee will count. Also pay by check or bank transfer, since a lender will want records.
What to check before you sign
This article is general information. A lawyer should read your contract before you sign it. Use this checklist first:
- Get it all in writing. LawHelpMN notes that the law does not enforce agreements to buy a house unless they are written down.
- Read which kind of agreement it is. Find the words that say whether you may buy or must buy.
- Find the split. The contract should say what part of each payment is rent and what part counts toward the price.
- Ask about the up-front payment. Learn what it buys and whether any of it comes back if you do not buy.
- Confirm the sale date and terms, including whether the sale uses a mortgage or a contract for deed.
- Look up the owner. Check the county recorder for who owns the home and for any mortgage or liens.
- Inspect it and check the value. Get a home inspection. Also, an appraisal can come in below the agreed price, which is a low appraisal.
- Talk to a lender now. Ask whether you could get a mortgage by the sale date and whether your credits will count.
- Meet a HUD-approved housing counselor. The CFPB’s housing counselor search lists HUD-approved agencies by ZIP code.
- Check your state’s law. Rules differ by state, and a local lawyer or legal aid office can tell you what applies.
Illinois: one example of a state rule
Illinois has a law for installment contracts, the Installment Sales Contract Act (765 ILCS 67), effective January 1, 2018. It covers deals, including contracts for deed, where the buyer agrees to buy and pays in installments for at least one year. The law applies to sellers who sign such contracts more than three times in 12 months.
Under Section 10, the seller must give a written contract with disclosures, including the price, any balloon payment and any known liens. Until both sides hold a copy signed by the buyer and seller with notarized signatures, either side may rescind. Section 20 also requires the seller to record the contract, or a memorandum of it, within 10 business days of the date of sale. A plain option to buy may fall outside the Act, so check with a lawyer.
Other ways to buy with little money or imperfect credit
Compare these paths with any rent-to-own offer first.
Low-down-payment loans
FHA loans allow 3.5% down with a credit score of 580 or higher, under HUD Handbook 4000.1, section II.A.2.b. Other programs allow little or nothing down for eligible buyers. Our guide to first-time home buyer loans compares them.
Down payment assistance
Many state and local programs help with a down payment. See our guide to down payment assistance programs for who qualifies.
Build credit first
If credit is the obstacle, read what lenders look for in our guide to the credit score to buy a house. Then see your options for a mortgage with bad credit.
Rent-to-own FAQ
Is rent-to-own a good idea?
It can work if the contract is fair, the seller owns the home, and you can get a mortgage in time. Still, compare it with low-down-payment loans and assistance programs first.
Why is rent-to-own bad?
Rent to own homes can carry costs and risks that a short ad does not explain. You can lose your up-front payment and credits if you do not buy. The seller may owe a mortgage, or may never plan to sell.
Do you get your money back if you do not buy?
It depends on the contract. LawHelpMN warns that you may not get an up-front down payment back if you do not buy, unlike a security deposit. Read the refund terms before you sign.
What happens if you miss a payment?
Under a lease with an option to buy, you are a tenant, so a missed payment can lead to eviction under state law. Under a contract for deed, the CFPB says the seller often tries to evict right away.
Can you get a mortgage after rent-to-own?
Yes, if you qualify when the sale date arrives. Fannie Mae and FHA count only the rent you paid above market rent as a credit. Ask a lender before you sign.
Is rent-to-own the same as a contract for deed?
No. With rent-to-own, you rent until you buy. With a contract for deed, you act as the owner right away while the seller keeps the title until the last payment.