On this page
Question: I’m a vet and recently heard that a VA mortgage has become more difficult to refinance for borrowers like me. What are the new rules and why is the VA making things harder for veterans?
Answer: The VA is on your side, and it hasn’t made refinancing a VA mortgage “harder” for vets. Instead, it has added rules that protect vets from predatory lenders. You want to support the VA in this matter.
What the VA loan program offers borrowers
The VA mortgage program is one of the benefits available to individuals with qualifying federal service, typically active-duty members of the military and vets no longer in the military. With VA financing a qualified borrower can finance the purchase of a home with zero down.
No less important, the VA has a flexible debt-to-income (DTI) standard. It uses a guideline of 41 percent of your gross monthly income going to recurring costs such as housing expenses, student loans, car payments, and credit card debt. It is a guideline, not a cap. A higher ratio can still be approved when your residual income is at least 20 percent above the VA’s guideline or other compensating factors apply.
Qualified Mortgage rules no longer set a 43 percent DTI limit; since October 2022 they use a price-based test instead. The VA’s ratio counts all of your monthly debt payments, including housing. What this really means is that if you’re a VA borrower and have stayed away from debt you can get a surprisingly large mortgage with nothing down.
The VA not only looks at a borrower’s DTI it also looks at residual income. In other words, how much cash is available to the borrower for general living expenses? The VA requires that borrowers have a given amount of cash available to them each month, depending on family size and where the property is located.
Click to check today’s VA refinance rates.
Why the rules for refinancing a VA mortgage changed
VA qualified borrowers can get financing to buy or refinance real estate. However, VA refinancing has a known problem. Some lenders talk the vet into refinancing with little benefit while they collect big fees and charges.
In May 2018, Congress passed the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act (Pub. L. 115-174). One section of the law relates to “protecting veterans from predatory lending,” and it added the refinancing protections now in 38 U.S.C. 3709. This is the reason that VA refinancing standards changed.
Okay, so what do these rules require? To prevent churning the legislation creates three requirements.
The fee recoupment test
Only the government could come up with a term such as “fee recoupment.” In plain language the law says that when a vet refinances a VA loan without taking cash out, the savings from the new loan must be sufficient to repay all fees, closing costs, and related expenses within 36 months. Such costs as money held in escrow and taxes do not count toward the cost calculation.
Example: the Smiths are advised to get a new VA loan. If they refinance they can save $100 a month. The cost to refinance is $5,000. The VA will not accept the refinance because the borrowers will not save at least $5,000 during the first three years of the new loan. However, if the cost to refinance had been $3,600 in this example, the loan would meet the recoupment test.
Net Tangible Benefit Test
One of the key goals from refinancing should be a net tangible benefit. That’s a fancy expression meaning the borrower should get something good from the transaction. The law requires the lender to give the vet a net tangible benefit test. VA rules list the benefits that count, such as a lower interest rate, a lower monthly payment, a shorter loan term, or a switch from an adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM) to a fixed rate.
When a vet refinances a VA loan without taking cash out, the rate cut must also meet a minimum. A fixed-rate loan replaced by a new fixed-rate loan needs a rate at least half a percent (50 basis points) lower. For a refinancing where an ARM will replace a fixed-rate loan, the interest rate must fall by at least 2 percent (200 basis points). There are also special rules which limit the use of discount points to reduce the interest rate.
The seasoning test
Predatory lenders often seek to refinance homes multiple times, a process called churning. Each time a lender refinances the loan, it collects big fees but the borrower sees little benefit. For instance, let’s say mortgage rates drop .50 percent. Instead of offering a new loan with a .50 percent rate cut, a predatory lender might offer to refinance the property to save the borrower .25 percent. A few months later the lender might offer to once again refinance the property for .25 percent. With each refinancing the lender collects thousands of dollars, money that the borrower could have saved.
Under these rules the VA will not guarantee a streamline refinance (IRRRL) until the later of six consecutive monthly payments on the loan being refinanced or 210 days after the first payment due date of that loan.
Cash-out refinancing of a VA mortgage
The 2018 law exempts cash-out refinancing, where the borrower gets a loan for more than the payoff on the old mortgage, from the three tests. Instead, it told the VA to write its own cash-out rules. Under those VA rules, every cash-out refinance must still pass a net tangible benefit test. A cash-out loan that pays off a VA loan must also meet the same seasoning period.
Are these rules somehow harsh or unfair? Not hardly, they prevent vets from paying more than they should to refinance a home. That’s good for vets, good for the VA and good for honest lenders.