On this page
  1. Why You Pay Back More Than You Borrowed
  2. A Fixed-Rate Mortgage Differs From Rent
  3. Each Payment Pays Down Part of the Loan
  4. Taxes Are Similar for Many Owners and Renters

Question: We went to see a lender, and what we learned about the total interest paid on a mortgage was terrifying. The lender says we can afford to borrow $225,000 at 7 percent interest. Our monthly payment will be $1,496.93 for principal and interest.

All of this sounded great until we found out that the total bill for our financing will be $538,895! Where does this number come from and doesn’t it make more sense to simply rent?

Answer: The odds that you will pay $539,000 for your mortgage are pretty much zero. It could happen, which is why the lender provided the figure, but in the real world, it’s implausible.

This example uses an illustrative 7 percent rate. For reference, Freddie Mac’s 30-year fixed-rate average was 7.11% on November 12, 2026.

Why You Pay Back More Than You Borrowed

Rent is something we can all understand. For the use of someone else’s property, you pay a monthly fee. If you rent an apartment for 30 years at $1,497 per month, the total cost will be about the same $539,000 (360 months x $1,497).

In practice, you will never pay $1,497 per month for an apartment because the landlord will increase the rent over time. Just think about rental rates five or ten years ago: same property and most likely a lower rent.

A mortgage is the same idea. You have the use of someone else’s property. Instead of an apartment, the lender’s “property” is the money it gives you at closing.

In basic terms, interest is the “rent” you pay for use of the lender’s money. For a $225,000 mortgage at 7 percent, the total interest paid (“rent”) over 30 years is $313,895. Combine $225,000 in principal with $313,895 in interest and the total is $538,895.

A Fixed-Rate Mortgage Differs From Rent

While rent and the payment of interest are parallel ideas, they are not the same, especially for savvy borrowers. If you finance with a fixed-rate mortgage, the cost for principal and interest never changes. You have locked in a big part of your future shelter costs. While the cost of taxes and insurance may go up, a fixed-rate mortgage gives borrowers a hedge against future rate hikes and higher monthly expenses.

Unlike a landlord with an apartment rent, lenders cannot increase the interest cost of fixed-rate mortgages. This is one of the very few cases in the world of finance where borrowers have leverage. While your fixed-rate mortgage is a wondrous financial vehicle for borrowers, lenders would really be happier if borrowers took out adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs), financing where the interest rate can go up.

Why do lenders offer fixed-rate mortgages (FRMs) if they prefer ARMs? The answer is that they’re not worried about loans being outstanding for 30 years, and neither should you. A loan ends early whenever the borrower refinances or sells the home and pays it off.

Each Payment Pays Down Part of the Loan

When we look at a mortgage, we see the amount borrowed, the interest rate, and the monthly payment. With a fixed-rate mortgage, the TOTAL amount paid each month for principal and interest never changes. However, each month the cost of interest declines because you pay down some of the principal.

For instance, look at the loan’s amortization statement. In month one the total payment is $1,496.93. Of this amount, $1,312.50 is interest and $184.43 is principal. A year later the monthly payment of $1,496.93 is unchanged, but now the interest cost in month 13 is $1,299.17 while the principal payment is $197.76. Slowly, over 30 years, the payments retire the whole mortgage: it’s a “self-amortizing” debt.

If you compare mortgage payments with rent, you can see a very important difference. When you pay rent the money is gone since it goes to the landlord. That’s not evil or unfair because you have had the use of the landlord’s property.

With a mortgage the situation is different. As you pay down the debt you owe less. If the value of the property does not change, or if it goes up, your wealth increases. In the case of the $225,000 mortgage at 7 percent, you will cut the debt by $2,286 by the end of the first year. At the end of two years the debt will be lower by $4,736. Etc. If you sell you will owe less to the lender and that can mean a larger check for you at closing.

Taxes Are Similar for Many Owners and Renters

The mortgage interest deduction is available if you itemize, on up to $750,000 of mortgage debt, and a 2025 law made the limits from the 2017 tax law permanent. Many owners take the standard deduction instead ($32,200 for a couple filing jointly and $16,100 for a single filer in 2026) because their itemized deductions are smaller. As a result, the mortgage interest and property tax deductions do not help many owners.

The tax benefits of rentals and owner-occupied homes are the same for many taxpayers. What won’t be the same is the ability to shelter costs with a fixed-rate mortgage, the gradual reduction of debt which can make us richer, and the potential for owner profits if home values rise.